Tracking down managed memory leaks

The first four steps to tracking down managed memory leaks.

If you think you've got memory leaks, or if you're just wondering what kind of stuff is on your heap you can follow...

the very same steps that I do and get fabulous results your friends will envy. OK, well maybe not, but they're handy anyway.

These steps will help you to go from a suspected memory leak to the specific object references that are keeping your objects alive. See the Resources at the end for the location of all these tools.

Step 1: Run your process and put it in the state you are curious about
Be sure to choose a scenario you can reproduce if that's at all possible, otherwise you'll never know if you're making headway in clearing out the memory leaks.

Step 2: Use tasklist to find its process ID


Image Name                   PID Session Name     Session#    Mem Usage
========================= ====== ================ ======== ============
System Idle Process            0 RDP-Tcp#9               0         16 K
System                         4 RDP-Tcp#9               0        112 K
smss.exe                     624 RDP-Tcp#9               0        252 K
ShowFormComplex.exe         4496 RDP-Tcp#9               0     20,708 K
tasklist.exe                3636 RDP-Tcp#9               0      4,180 K

From here we can see that my process is ID #4496

Step 3: Use VADump to get a summary of the process

C:\>vadump -sop 4496
Category                   Total        Private  Shareable    Shared
                      Pages    KBytes    KBytes     KBytes    KBytes
 Page Table Pages        35       140       140         0         0
 Other System            15        60        60         0         0
 Code/StaticData       4596     18384      4020      3376     10988
 Heap                   215       860       860         0         0
 Stack                   30       120       120         0         0
 Teb                      4        16        16         0         0
 Mapped Data            129       516         0        24       492
 Other Data             157       628       624         4         0

 Total Modules          4596     18384      4020      3376     10988
 Total Dynamic Data      535      2140      1620        28       492
 Total System             50       200       200         0         0
Grand Total Working Set 5181     20724      5840      3404     11480

Here we can see that the process is mostly code (18384k)

The vast majority of the resources that the CLR uses are under "Other Data" -- this is because the GC Heap is directly allocated with VirtualAlloc -- it doesn't go through a regular windows heap. And same for the so-called "loader heaps" which hold type information and jitted code. Most of the conventional "Heap" allocations are from whatever unmanaged is running. In this case it's a winform application with piles of controls so there's storage associated with those things.

There isn't much "Other Data" here so the heap situation is probably pretty good but let's see where we stand on detailed CLR memory usage.

Step 4: Attach Windbg and load SOS

C:\> windbg -p 4496

Once the debugger loads use this command to load our extension DLL

0:004> .loadby sos mscorwks

This tells the debugger to load the extension "sos.dll" from the same place that mscorwks.dll was loaded. That ensures that you get the right version of SOS (it should be the one that matches the mscorwks you are using).

Click here to read the remaining four steps to this process.

Rico Mariani is a Performance Architect in the Developer Division at Microsoft. Rico began his career at Microsoft in 1988, working on language products beginning with Microsoft C version 6.0, and contributed there until the release of the Microsoft Visual C++ version 5.0 development system. In 1995, Rico became development manager for what was to become the "Sidewalk" project, which started his 7 years of platform work on various MSN technologies. In the summer of 2002, Rico returned to the Developer Division to take his present position as Performance Architect on the CLR team. Rico's interests include compilers and language theory, databases, 3-D art, and good fiction.

This was last published in December 2004

Dig Deeper on Microsoft .NET Web services



Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.



Forgot Password?

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an email containing your password.

Your password has been sent to: